Q&A: Can My Board Eliminate a Children’s Playground?

Q. I purchased my condo unit in 2005 with amenities, including 24-hour security, two pools, a parking lot, and a children’s playground. This past summer, our board destroyed the children’s playground and made it into additional parking space for rent.  None of the homeowners were informed about that. When I asked about it, I got an answer that the playground was in bad shape and costs extra money for insurance, and that the kids can use any of the nearby parks for playing.  Is this action by the board legal?

                                              —Irate Tenant

A. “Possibly not,” says attorney Michael C. Kim of the Chicago-based firm Michael C. Kim and Associates. “Generally, the board of directors has the fiduciary duty to maintain the common elements/amenities of the condominium.  Unit owners presumably purchase their units with the expectation that the existing amenities would generally be available for them and their guests.  However, the board does have discretion as to the amenities, which may involve the timing and feasibility of maintenance, insurance considerations, new legal requirements or restrictions, and even possible change if so desired by the current membership. Substitution of the playground with additional rental parking space may be arguably understandable if there was a dire shortage of parking for residents, as opposed to simply seeking to generate more income.  If a particular amenity is fundamental to the identity/purpose of the condominium, the elimination of that amenity may require unit owner approval.  In addition, it is not unusual that declaration/bylaws may have an expenditure limitation for any capital improvements or modifications above a certain dollar amount; in that regard, the board may need to obtain the approval of the unit owners for any such capital improvements or alterations.  Of course, the ultimate check on the actions taken by the board is whether the unit owners will either re-elect or even remove directors who appear to be acting inconsistent with the expectations of the membership.  Finally, the elimination of the children’s playground might be viewed as discriminatory against residents with children.”                           

Related Articles

Q&A: When a Board Prez Takes Over Treasury Duties

Q&A: When a Board Prez Takes Over Treasury Duties

Q&A: Changing the House Rules

Q&A: Changing the House Rules

Q&A: Getting an Owner to Maintain Proper Upkeep of His Unit

Q&A: Getting an Owner to Maintain Proper Upkeep of His Unit

Aesthetic Rules in Co-ops, Condos & HOAs

A Matter of Taste?

Q&A: When a Management Company Takes Over

Q&A: When a Management Company Takes Over

Denying Access

Consequences for Arrears and Non-Payment

 

Comments

  • Hi. I believe a contractor is ripping us off and we don't know where to turn. The Village of Addison inspector has deemed that we must REPLACE (not repair) all our outdoor concrete stairs and landings. Our contractor originally said it would cost $67,000 per building. Now he's saying $328,000.00 per building. There are 3 staircases and sets of landings per building, 3 stories high. Many of us who live there are low income or near that, or senior citizens. We can barely afford the mortgages and assessments, let alone an additional $8,000.00 per unit. People have said things, like it could have been repaired. And maybe the inspector is friends with the contactor? Can you please help us?